Having an eight-year old boy who sees school as nothing more than time to socialize with other kids is challenging, to say the least. Having an eight-year old boy who is stubborn as hell and sees no reason why he has to come up with three ways to get to an answer, regardless of what the teacher tells him he has to do, leads to a battle every night when it's homework time.
Let's just say that my son is not a fan of education today. Neither is his mother. After spending a day out and about and having to deal with many charming and ever so polite teenagers at cash registers and restaurants, I'm convinced that these kids are way dumber than even the slowest kids I graduated with way back in the day when you memorized your facts and only had to get the fucking answer right. Nobody asked how you know the right answer, unless you were suspected of cheating, because what's the point.
"Showing your work" and explaining in a sentence how you know that 4 + 4 = 8 has turned these teens into idiot zombies who cannot do simple math or carry on a very basic conversation. When I'm in the checkout line or the customer service line, the only thing that matters to me is that you come up with the right answer as quickly as possible. I couldn't give a fuck how you get there, and I surely don't want to hear your "logic." The kicker was the college student waitress who admitted after watching me finesse my John Hancock on a receipt after three delicious margaritas, mind you, that she has no idea how to sign her name unless she prints it.
So, why am I spending my summer trying to teach the boy cursive writing before he starts third grade and is expected to pick it up in the three months they spend teaching it so that he can use it to do his work exclusively in fourth grade, only to be told in fifth that he can print again, because everything becomes about the computer? Um, because my friends with older kids told me to, just like they told me that I was supposed to teach the boy his math facts, because they don't do that anymore in school. Unfortunately, they told me too late, so we spent our summers having fun instead of learning what he will never learn in school. Seems like a letter home at the end of each school year, detailing what they will be expected to have learned at home or by osmosis would be a good idea.
Of course, that would be too much to expect from our school system, you know, because they're too busy overthinking every speck of minutia because the test they're teaching to requires overthinking everything to death, and we can't have low test scores in MA, after all. The funny thing about that is since the schools began the whole new math and nothing can be correct unless you write an essay to explain why you know the answer, I've noticed that many kids that are graduating are not all that smart. Maybe their minds went to mush, as mine would have, if you made me learn that way or maybe it's a flawed idea from the get-go, because some kids just can't learn that way and aren't so great at writing a paragraph in answer to a simple yes or no question.
I was an A student, honor roll most of the time, but I'd probably flunk right out of high school with this sort of teaching. My brain doesn't work that way. I was and always will be a memorizer. What's wrong with that? The answer is the answer is the answer, unless you're an engineer or a scientist, and in my job I've witnessed how hard it is for some of them to think their way out of a cardboard box. Simple common sense gets lost when you overanalyze too much.
Old math worked just fine, people. I mean, we managed to get men on the moon and build incredible bridges and buildings way back when it was okay to carry the one when adding, and even though I hump my calculator 99.9% of the time, I can still write out a good, old-fashioned math problem if need be and come up with the correct answer. Oh, and I can do my times tables up to twelvesies and short division in my head. You'll get no explanation out of me as to how I came up with the answer beyond the obvious, "I memorized them in fourth grade," and I won't show you three other ways to get there, but I guarantee I'll get there faster than most of these poor kids today.
Sure, some kids can handle this way of teaching and thrive, so you parents of math geeks and critical thinkers need not tell me just how wrong and stupid I am. You happy-go-lucky overthinkers just keep on keepin' on. I mean you no harm. I'm just a mother of a kid who could have such a better experience with his school years if there wasn't this one size fits all, every brain must work the same way mentality in public schools today. In my day, there were general classes, and there were AP classes for just this reason, and the system worked much better. We all got a decent education that way, and some of the most successful people I know were in the general classes.
Will I throw in the towel and all of our savings to send the boy to a private school some day? Maybe. Will I say "fuck that," save my money and homeschool him? Highly unlikely, since I value my sanity and don't want to become a pill addict, but if his spirit keeps getting crushed by attending school, I'll swallow a handful of pills each day and gives him a fine edumication. That will be the last step, however, because we're simply not meant to be together all day, every day. We're too much alike.
For now, though, we're spending a little time each day at Lola's Summa Skool doing workbook pages designed to get him ready for third grade, and he's seeing his reading tutor weekly, in hopes that we can get a jump-start this year and avoid the shitty report cards and dire warnings of years past that he's not meeting grade standard. He's not happy about it, and neither am I, since it's becoming pretty obvious that my math skills are not up to third grade level.
I swear, if I have to watch the poor kid draw another number line to plot out the answer to 60 - 25, my head might explode, and I'm trying desperately to bite my pencil and not teach the kid to carry the one so he can do simple fucking math in a timely manner. It's KILLING ME, but we wouldn't want him to be suspended over using outdated math practices, now would we?
Thursday, July 9, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


17 comments:
I swear, I'm going to slap the shit out of a school official later today in honor of you and your boy.
My logic for this? Mother fuckers deserve it.
Yeah, what’s wrong with the three “R’s”?
Readin’ Ritin’ & Rithmatic.
Is this what I have in my not so distant future? Math is bad enough, but throw reasoning and logic and explanations into it and I'll be totally lost if I try to help Will.
Sometimes I got the answer but I didn't know how. That should be good enough!
They need to stop teaching to the MCAS test, but it's a brave new world and MCAS means EVERYTHING to a teacher. The teachers are reviewed and a big part of it is how many of their students passed MCAS. That test has literally taken over the classroom and the educational system in this state, which is a shame because I've seen it destroy lives.
The first year it became mandatory to graduate, one girl took it 7 times and had all these tutors but couldn't pass because of a learning disability. But because of No Child Left Behind it didn't matter. So she couldn't walk across the stage with friends, she couldn't get her diploma and then she couldn't get a good job after high school. She ended up overdosing on drugs two years later.
I fucking hate MCAS.
Ugh. Don't get me started about the education system today.
I get all hot and bothered.
I feel your pain on the young idiots that are populating our country these days. I also agree with the fact that all kids do not learn the same. I, too, am a memorizer. And it has served me well. I hope you get to enjoy some of your summer!
Are you kidding me? Is that really how it is done?
Wow...I guess I am glad that lil moonspun is doing well in her waldorf school, even if sometimes they write sometimes like 8=4+4...whatever, she knows what it means and it makes sense to her.
The thing that gets me about cashiers is that NO ONE young can ever count back change. Like if you give a $10 and they count back UP to the $10 with the change. Isn't that basic math???
Spot ON!
My point of irritation is how the athletes are treated inside the walls of the school ... don't get me started either.
I'm actually looking forward to seeing how "it's done" in an international "American" school. Hoping for all of our sakes (teenager included) that it's better? A girl can hope, right?
Monkey: Aww, you're the best!! Hit 'em hard!!!!
3699: Exactly.
Daddy: Oh, man, you have no idea. My mother quit teaching fourth grade after 30 happy years over teaching to that stupid test. The MCAS is a fucking joke, always has been.
They made it incredibly difficult in the first few years, which made our kids look like glorified idiots, and then they dumbed it down a little to make it look like our kids are learning so much more.
As for the No Child Left Behind, it's great in theory, but in some cases it ties the teachers' hands and hurts everyone in the class with a very disruptive kid. My son had a girl in his class this past year that would freak out and start flipping over desks every time the teacher told her "No." So, what did they do? Moved 23 other kids to another room until she calmed down, which was over a half hour at times.
Sadly, lots of kids, like my own, with no learning disabilites cannot keep up with the ever-changing curriculum, new math programs, and it's a total disaster. All I can say is you better get some books and start working with Will NOW! You'll need that much time to learn it for yourself ;)
Badass: And you're a geek!!! Think about the rest of us dummies.
Nonya: But they had a much better education than we did, right? It's not really summer here yet, what with the rain and the 60-degree temps, so I don't feel like I'm missing much ;(
Moon: Sadly, the girl I dealt with at Staples couldn't even do that, but she told me she was right and explained her logic to the manager, who was my age. He proceeded to apologize to me before fixing her mistake.
Naomi: You'll probably be pleasantly surprised in India. The special treatment athletes get in college is a total disgrace!
If you let me wear your red gogo boots I promise I'll also punch 'em in the neck and possibly even dot their eye with my crow bar.
Just think about it.
Oh, and did you see how you got BAG all hot n' bothered again? I just love that.
OMG, I hate, hate, hate the new math bullshit. Little J is gonna be in 4th grade, and all year, his teacher kept telling me how he had the right answers in math, but he didn't write out all the steps like he was supposed to.
They have to write out paragraphs about how they found the answer...
and apparently in fourth grade, it becomes much more important to be able to do this. Bullshit.
And NCLB? Even more bullshit.
Monkey: What are you doing back here? You're supposed to be kickin' ass for me. Honey, I'll let you wear my gogo boots while you beat them. They are so comfortable that you could go ten rounds and run from the cops afterwards ;)
I always get BAG worked up. It's my job.
It would be great if those standards were even universal. My poor niece learned the "old fashioned way" and then when they moved to another state, they do math "the new way" without carrying, and she had to learn it all over again. My sister had to pay for a tutor, despite extra tutoring after school from the actual teacher. It's ridiculous. My daughter missed out on that whole trend fortunately. She learned the old way and EXCELS at math. Way better than I ever was, I could barely pass algebra, and she's going into Pre-calc.
My daughter's high school also has a "block scheduling" system which SUCKS. Great giant donkey balls. They take 8 classes - 4 the first half of the year, and 4 the second half. Which means when they have things like AP tests, the jerks who didn't get to take the class til the second half of the year get screwed BIG TIME. Also, there are some classes like band which you are forced to take all year. That's like taking it twice on a normal schedule, so to be in band, my daughter can only take one other elective for half the year. It's the stupidest system I've ever seen.
First off....please get Badass hot and bothered. It's something fun for everyone.
The education system sucks. Plain and simple. We made it thru just fine, they should got back to the old way.
I wish they would just do year round school then we wouldn't have to be bothered with the supplementing!
and even though I hump my calculator 99.9% of the time, I can still write out a good, old-fashioned math problem if need be and come up with the correct answer
I just inhaled my margarita when I read this. It doesn't taste as good coming our my nose.
Anyway, although we're a couple years off from the School System Made Of Fail, I hear ya. Who the fuck cares how I know the answer, as long as I do?
Sadly, this is not a new phenomenon. When I was in grade school, back when dinosaurs roamed the earth, in 4th grade I was doing some long division. My dad, who is incredibly quick with numbers, showed me a shortcut whereby I could eliminate 20 of the 22 rows of stupid "work" and still get the answer.
I got a zero for not showing my work. My dad threw a fit. I still had to re-do it all. I didn't learn it any better or faster their way, but apparently, the sky would have fallen if I didin't complete all 22 rows.
New Math totally fucked me up.
Post a Comment